Shop Our Weekly Sale

See More
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Lefty 2000 the Donkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Lefty 2000 the Donkey
Sale price: $4.25 Price:$5.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Independence the White Bear
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Independence the White Bear
Sale price: $5.10 Price:$6.00
Only 5 left
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Spangle the Bear - Pink Face
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Spangle the Bear - Pink Face
Sale price: $5.10 Price:$6.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: America the Bear- Blue
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: America the Bear- Blue
Sale price: $5.10 Price:$6.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Uncle Sam the Bear - Blue Nose
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Uncle Sam the Bear - Blue Nose
Sale price: $5.95 Price:$7.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Lefty 2004 the Donkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Lefty 2004 the Donkey
Sale price: $4.25 Price:$5.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Pillow Pal: Sparkler the Bear
Ty Ty Pillow Pal: Sparkler the Bear
Sale price: $9.35 Price:$11.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Sam the Bear - Blue
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Sam the Bear - Blue
Sale price: $5.10 Price:$6.00
In Stock

Shop Beanie Babies

View all
Authenticated Beanie Baby: 3rd Generation Splash the WhaleAuthenticated Beanie Baby: 3rd Generation Splash the Whale
Ty Beanie Baby: Slapshot the Penguin
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Slapshot the Penguin
Sale price: $24.00
Only 2 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Nutty the Squirrel
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Nutty the Squirrel
Sale price: $11.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Pinata the Bear - Flag Nose
Ty Beanie Baby: Odie the Dog - Garfield
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Odie the Dog - Garfield
Sale price: $14.00
Only 4 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Swampy the Alligator
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Swampy the Alligator
Sale price: $6.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Iggy the Iguana - No Tongue
Ty Beanie Baby: Sparkly Pink Sock Monkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Sparkly Pink Sock Monkey
Sale price: $19.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Blizzard the White Tiger
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Blizzard the White Tiger
Sale price: $9.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Happy Holidays the Bear
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Happy Holidays the Bear
Sale price: $8.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Scorch the Dragon
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Scorch the Dragon
Sale price: $9.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Issy Cairo the Four Seasons Hotel Bear

Recently Restocked

View all
Hallmark Ornament: 2006 Snow Buddies | QX2473 | 9th in SeriesHallmark Ornament: 2006 Snow Buddies | QX2473 | 9th in Series
Ty Beanie Baby: Derby 132 the Horse
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Derby 132 the Horse
Sale price: $9.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Bonsai the Chimpanzee
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Bonsai the Chimpanzee
Sale price: $10.00
Only 4 left
Ty Beanie Boo: Kiwi the Bird - Glitter Eyes, Regular Size
Hallmark Ornament: 2013 Marcus Allen | QXI2292 | NFLHallmark Ornament: 2013 Marcus Allen | QXI2292 | NFL
Hallmark Ornament: 2003 Around the World | QXI7489 | Harley-DavidsonHallmark Ornament: 2003 Around the World | QXI7489 | Harley-Davidson
2004 Holiday Barbie (B5848) - Green Dress2004 Holiday Barbie (B5848) - Green Dress
Mattel 2004 Holiday Barbie (B5848) - Green Dress
Sale price: From $79.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 2007 Freedom Train Locomotive | QX2347 | 12th in SeriesHallmark Ornament: 2007 Freedom Train Locomotive | QX2347 | 12th in Series
Ty Beanie Baby: Cheddar the Mouse
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Cheddar the Mouse
Sale price: $13.00
Only 3 left
Lladró Figurine: 4612 Girl Singer
Lladró Lladró Figurine: 4612 Girl Singer
Sale price: From $39.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 2016 U.S.S. Enterprise | QXI3404 | Gold EditionHallmark Ornament: 2016 U.S.S. Enterprise | QXI3404 | Gold Edition
Hallmark Ornament: 2006 Snow Buddies | QX2473-C | 9th in SeriesHallmark Ornament: 2006 Snow Buddies | QX2473-C | 9th in Series

What Our Customers Are Saying

"My daughter took a shine to beanie babies at her local library and I was delighted to find Treasure Keeper offers such affordable toys with flat, affordable shipping. My daughter delighted in picking out her favorites and was overjoyed when they arrived."

--Andrea H. May 2024

"Love, love, love. Exactly as ordered and fast shipping meant I got my beanie baby quickly! 10 out of 10 would recommend."

-- Angelica T. June 2024

"I recommend Treasure Keeper due to their easy shopping website, fair prices, service and fast delivery! You place an order and the next business day, they ship your order, and they then email you the tracking, so you have an ETA for your order."

--David S. May 2023

Shop Figurines

View all
WDCC Queen - Now Begins Thy Magic Spell | 4010334 | Disney's Snow WhiteWDCC Queen - Now Begins Thy Magic Spell | 4010334 | Disney's Snow White
Nao by Lladró Figurine: 118 Little Shepard of the Andes
WDCC Cinderella - Royal Introduction | 4015614 | Disney | Limited to 750WDCC Cinderella - Royal Introduction | 4015614 | Disney | Limited to 750
Precious Moments Figurine: E-3110B Loving is Sharing
Hummel Figurine: 84/0, Worship
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Worship - 84/0
Sale price: From $70.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
WDCC  Opening Title | 41083 | Disney's Snow WhiteWDCC  Opening Title | 41083 | Disney's Snow White
Disney WDCC Opening Title | 41083 | Disney's Snow White
Sale price: From $43.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Department 56: 56373 Delivering The Christmas Greens - Set of 2
Hummel Figurine: 163, Whitsuntide
WDCC Base - The Curse is Broken-As is | Limited to 1000WDCC Base - The Curse is Broken-As is | Limited to 1000
Lladró Figurine: 1506 A New Friend
Lladró Lladró Figurine: 1506 A New Friend
Sale price: From $162.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Lladró Figurine: 8693 Curious KittensLladró Figurine: 8693 Curious Kittens
Lladró Lladró Figurine: 8693 Curious Kittens
Sale price: From $298.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
WDCC Koda - Sitting Cub | 1234320 | Disney's Brother BearWDCC Koda - Sitting Cub | 1234320 | Disney's Brother Bear

Shop By Brand

Shop Designer Hand Bags

View all
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Ivory Leather Convertible Crossbody BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Ivory Leather Convertible Crossbody Bag
Coach Purse: F14482 Brown Horse Carriage Tote BagCoach Purse: F14482 Brown Horse Carriage Tote Bag
Coach Purse: F17599 Black Ashley Shoulder BagCoach Purse: F17599 Black Ashley Shoulder Bag
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Red Checked Tweed Signature Shoulder BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Red Checked Tweed Signature Shoulder Bag
BCBGMAXAZRIA Purse: Driftwood Large Tote BagBCBGMAXAZRIA Purse: Driftwood Large Tote Bag
Judith Leiber Purse: Black Suede Rhinestone Clutch Shoulder BagJudith Leiber Purse: Black Suede Rhinestone Clutch Shoulder Bag
Coach Purse: 18306 Silver Hobo BagCoach Purse: 18306 Silver Hobo Bag
Coach Coach Purse: 18306 Silver Hobo Bag
Sale price: $85.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: F27481 Black Taylor Shoulder BagCoach Purse: F27481 Black Taylor Shoulder Bag
B Makowsky Purse: Black Leather Convertible HandbagB Makowsky Purse: Black Leather Convertible Handbag
Sharif Purse: Color Block Leather Crossbody BagSharif Purse: Color Block Leather Crossbody Bag
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Navy Signature Tote BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Navy Signature Tote Bag
Fiore Purse: Grey Embroidery Stitch Leather Hobo BagFiore Purse: Grey Embroidery Stitch Leather Hobo Bag

Recently viewed