TY Newest Additions
Just Listed
All Beanie Babies
Recently Restocked
Hallmark Ornaments
Halloween
Welcome Fall
Lladró
Precious Moments
Swarovski Crystal
Warehouse Finds
Hallmark Ornaments
Shop Christmas Treasures

Maria B. Says:

"I would highly recommend this seller. Very fast shipping. Good communication"

Just Listed - Hallmark Ornaments

Need These!

Katie L. Says

"Love this online store! A great small business that is very responsive, fast shipping & quality products!"
Recent Restocks

Shop the Latest TY Treasures

See More
Teeny Tys - Windsor the BearTeeny Tys - Windsor the Bear
TY Teeny Tys - Windsor the Bear
$14.97
In Stock
Ty Flippables Sequin Plush - Stompy the Pink DinosaurTy Flippables Sequin Plush - Stompy the Pink Dinosaur
TY Ty Flippables Sequin Plush - Stompy the Pink Dinosaur
$16.97
Only 2 left
Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Frights the Halloween CatTy Halloweenie Beanies - Frights the Halloween Cat
TY Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Frights the Halloween Cat
$12.97
Only 2 left
Ty Beanie Baby - Nibbler the Gray Bunny, (3")Ty Beanie Baby - Nibbler the Gray Bunny, (3")
TY Ty Beanie Baby - Nibbler the Gray Bunny, (3")
$20.97
Only 3 left
Beanie Ballz- Batty the Bat, Glitter EyesBeanie Ballz- Batty the Bat, Glitter Eyes
TY Beanie Ballz- Batty the Bat, Glitter Eyes
$21.97
In Stock
Ty Beanie Boos (Plastic Key Clip) - Legs the Purple Octopus, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos (Plastic Key Clip) - Legs the Purple Octopus, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos (Plastic Key Clip) - Legs the Purple Octopus, Glitter Eyes
$5.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Cora the Orange Owl, (6"), Glitter Eyes, Justice StoresTy Beanie Boos - Cora the Orange Owl, (6"), Glitter Eyes, Justice Stores
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Cora the Orange Owl, (6"), Glitter Eyes, Justice Stores
$71.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Gatsby the Dog, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Gatsby the Dog, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Gatsby the Dog, Glitter Eyes
$31.97
Only 1 left

Shop Curated Gift Collections

View all
Gifts for 90's Kids
Gifts for Disney Lovers
Gifts for Boys
Gifts for Moms
Gifts for Girls
Gifts for Grandmas
Gifts for Grandpas
Gifts for Dads
Collection's name

Recently Restocked

View all
Hallmark Ornament: 1990 Donder's Diner | QX4823Hallmark Ornament: 1990 Donder's Diner | QX4823
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1990 Donder's Diner | QX4823
From $7.97
Only 3 left
Choose options
Ty Buddy: Lizzy the Lizard
TY Ty Buddy: Lizzy the Lizard
$15.00
In Stock
Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Holiday Café | QX5399Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Holiday Café | QX5399
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Holiday Café | QX5399
From $7.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments Ornament: 160334 An Event Filled with Sunshine & Smiles | DatedPrecious Moments Ornament: 160334 An Event Filled with Sunshine & Smiles | Dated
Precious Moments Precious Moments Ornament: 160334 An Event Filled with Sunshine & Smiles | Dated
$7.00
Only 1 left
Hummel Figurine: Little Goat Herder - 200/0Hummel Figurine: Little Goat Herder - 200/0
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Little Goat Herder - 200/0
From $55.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
Beanie Babies- Bumper the Hedgehog, Glitter EyesBeanie Babies- Bumper the Hedgehog, Glitter Eyes
TY Beanie Babies- Bumper the Hedgehog, Glitter Eyes
$8.97
Only 1 left
1977 PD US Mint Set (OGP) 12 coins with Eisenhower Dollar1977 PD US Mint Set (OGP) 12 coins with Eisenhower Dollar
U.S. Mint 1977 PD US Mint Set (OGP) 12 coins with Eisenhower Dollar
$15.00
Only 2 left
Precious Moments: 527564 God Bless the USAPrecious Moments: 527564 God Bless the USA
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 527564 God Bless the USA
$9.00
Only 2 left
Swarovski Candle Holder: 010077 Pin Style - European
Swarovski Swarovski Candle Holder: 010077 Pin Style - European
From $70.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 56397 Santa's Light Shop
Department 56 Department 56: 56397 Santa's Light Shop
From $63.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Swarovski Figurine: 010177 Cigarette Holder - Clear
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 010177 Cigarette Holder - Clear
From $85.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Antique German China Head DollAntique German China Head Doll
German Doll Antique German China Head Doll
$30.00
Only 1 left

What Our Customers Are Saying

"Treasure Keeper is my go to source for unique & vintage collectible items."

-- Connie B. Oct 2026

"Even more beautiful in person, this was my first purchase and it was a great experience. It came rather quickly impact safe and securely with no issues whatsoever."

-- Suzon L. August 2026

"Excellent condition exactly as shown and very fast. Would definitely order from here again. Thank you!"

-- John D. Oct 2026

Read More Reviews

Shop Figurines

View all
Precious Moments: 529567 Sam Butcher | Sugar TownPrecious Moments: 529567 Sam Butcher | Sugar Town
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 529567 Sam Butcher | Sugar Town
$8.00
Only 3 left
Precious Moments: 272671 Cane You Join Us for a Merry Christmas | DatedPrecious Moments: 272671 Cane You Join Us for a Merry Christmas | Dated
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 272671 Cane You Join Us for a Merry Christmas | Dated
$11.00
In Stock
Vintage Andrea by Sadek Owl Bookends Pair, Hand Painted Ceramic Owl Library DécorVintage Andrea by Sadek Owl Bookends Pair, Hand Painted Ceramic Owl Library Décor
Andrea by Sadek Vintage Andrea by Sadek Owl Bookends Pair, Hand Painted Ceramic Owl Library Décor
$60.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski Crystal Figurine Pink Heart, Kris Bear, 5265323Swarovski Crystal Figurine Pink Heart, Kris Bear, 5265323
Swarovski Swarovski Crystal Figurine Pink Heart, Kris Bear, 5265323
From $139.97
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hummel Figurine: Keeping Time - 2183Hummel Figurine: Keeping Time - 2183
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Keeping Time - 2183
From $33.00
Only 5 left
Choose options
Lladró Figurine: Nao 109 Just MarriedLladró Figurine: Nao 109 Just Married
Lladró Lladró Figurine: Nao 109 Just Married
From $55.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments: PM952 Always Take Time to PrayPrecious Moments: PM952 Always Take Time to Pray
Precious Moments Precious Moments: PM952 Always Take Time to Pray
$8.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski Crystal: 208433 Anniversary Squirrel
Swarovski Swarovski Crystal: 208433 Anniversary Squirrel
From $63.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments: 521477 Tell It to JesusPrecious Moments: 521477 Tell It to Jesus
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 521477 Tell It to Jesus
$21.00
Only 2 left
Royal Doulton - Greta HN 1485 Figurine Leslie Harradine Bone China England 5.5"Royal Doulton - Greta HN 1485 Figurine Leslie Harradine Bone China England 5.5"
Royal Doulton Royal Doulton - Greta HN 1485 Figurine Leslie Harradine Bone China England 5.5"
$100.00
Only 1 left
Hummel Figurine: Little Scholar - 80Hummel Figurine: Little Scholar - 80
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Little Scholar - 80
From $33.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Giuseppe Armani Figurine: 490c HarlequinGiuseppe Armani Figurine: 490c Harlequin
Giuseppe Armani Giuseppe Armani Figurine: 490c Harlequin
From $165.00
Only 1 left
Choose options

Shop By Brand

FREE Shipping!

All orders over $40 ship for FREE

SHOP NOW

Thousands of 5 Star Reviews

Two decades of experience + Our passion for service = A great buying experience for you!

VIEW OUR REVIEWS

Proud to Be a Family Business

Serving Families like yours since 1999

READ OUR STORY

Shop Designer Hand Bags

View all
Walborg Purse: Black Beaded Evening Clutch BagWalborg Purse: Black Beaded Evening Clutch Bag
Wabarg Walborg Purse: Black Beaded Evening Clutch Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: 41207 Black Signature Crossbody BagCoach Purse: 41207 Black Signature Crossbody Bag
Coach Coach Purse: 41207 Black Signature Crossbody Bag
$50.00
Only 1 left
Handmade Purse: Cream Beaded Evening Shoulder BagHandmade Purse: Cream Beaded Evening Shoulder Bag
Handmade Handmade Purse: Cream Beaded Evening Shoulder Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Gold Signature Crossbody BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Gold Signature Crossbody Bag
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Gold Signature Crossbody Bag
$75.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet HandbagDooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet Handbag
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet Handbag
$35.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Green AWL Dover Crossbody BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Green AWL Dover Crossbody Bag
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Green AWL Dover Crossbody Bag
$98.00
Only 1 left
Fiore Purse: Grey Embroidery Stitch Leather Hobo BagFiore Purse: Grey Embroidery Stitch Leather Hobo Bag
Fiore Fiore Purse: Grey Embroidery Stitch Leather Hobo Bag
$85.00
Only 1 left
Sharif Purse: Color Block Leather Crossbody BagSharif Purse: Color Block Leather Crossbody Bag
Sharif Sharif Purse: Color Block Leather Crossbody Bag
$85.00
Only 1 left
Lancome Purse: Lot of 5 Cosmetic Travel Pouch BagLancome Purse: Lot of 5 Cosmetic Travel Pouch Bag
Lancome Lancome Purse: Lot of 5 Cosmetic Travel Pouch Bag
$35.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: F20048 Purple Black Ocelet Poppy Shoulder BagCoach Purse: F20048 Purple Black Ocelet Poppy Shoulder Bag
Coach Coach Purse: F20048 Purple Black Ocelet Poppy Shoulder Bag
$169.00
Only 1 left
Harry Levine Purse: White Ostrich Leather Evening Clutch BagHarry Levine Purse: White Ostrich Leather Evening Clutch Bag
Harry Levine Harry Levine Purse: White Ostrich Leather Evening Clutch Bag
$125.00
Only 1 left
Oryany Purse: Tan Sydney Color-Block Shoulder BagOryany Purse: Tan Sydney Color-Block Shoulder Bag
Oryany Oryany Purse: Tan Sydney Color-Block Shoulder Bag
$235.00
Only 1 left

Recently viewed