Lladró
Recently Restocked
All Beanie Babies
Hummel
Waterford
Disney
Just Listed
Welcome Fall
Swarovski Crystal
Football
Hallmark Ornaments
All Barbies
On Sale Now

Laurie B. Says:

"Wonderful variety of inventory to satisfy everyone's need, along with impeccable customer service."
Check 'Em Out

Barbara A. Says:

"Thank you for sending this so quickly and in excellent condition!"
Hallmark Ornaments

Shop Our Weekly Sale

See More
Save 15%
Waterford Crystal: Comeragh Footed Bowl, 5.5"Waterford Crystal: Comeragh Footed Bowl, 5.5"
Waterford Waterford Crystal: Comeragh Footed Bowl, 5.5"
$28.90 $34.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Lurkey the Turkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Lurkey the Turkey
$9.35 $11.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Tommy the Turkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Tommy the Turkey
$8.50 $10.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Tom-e Turkey
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Tom-e Turkey
$10.20 $12.00
In Stock
Save 15%
Ty Beanie Baby: Stuffed the Turkey BBOM November 2006
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Stuffed the Turkey BBOM November 2006
$12.75 $15.00
Only 2 left
Save 15%
Waterford Stemware, Harvest Thanksgiving Water Goblet, 8.75"Waterford Stemware, Harvest Thanksgiving Water Goblet, 8.75"
Waterford Waterford Stemware, Harvest Thanksgiving Water Goblet, 8.75"
$47.60 $56.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Save 15%
Waterford Crystal: Lismore Scalloped Bowl, 9"Waterford Crystal: Lismore Scalloped Bowl, 9"
Waterford Waterford Crystal: Lismore Scalloped Bowl, 9"
$57.80 $68.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Save 15%
#REF!
Warner Bros Warner Bros. Plush: Tweety Bird as an Indian
$16.15 $19.00
Only 4 left

Shop Best Sellers

View all
Ty Beanie Baby: Cheezer the Mouse
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Cheezer the Mouse
$21.00
Only 5 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Jabber the Parrot
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Jabber the Parrot
$6.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Amber the CatTy Beanie Baby: Amber the Cat
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Amber the Cat
$15.00
In Stock
Hummel Figurine: 374, Lost Stocking
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Lost Stocking - 374
From $27.00
Only 4 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Pinky the Flamingo
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Pinky the Flamingo
$5.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Kirby the Dog
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Kirby the Dog
$7.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: America the Bear- Red
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: America the Bear- Red
$5.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Bernie the St. Bernard Dog
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Bernie the St. Bernard Dog
$5.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Hippity the Bunny
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Hippity the Bunny
$7.00
In Stock
Ty Buddy: Patti the Platypus
Ty Ty Buddy: Patti the Platypus
$12.00
Only 2 left
Swarovski Figurine: 119747 Waterlilly Candle Holder
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 119747 Waterlilly Candle Holder
From $350.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Gift the Bear - Love
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Gift the Bear - Love
$7.00
In Stock

Recently Restocked

View all
Ty Beanie Baby: Sport the Dog
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Sport the Dog
$5.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Graf Von Rot the Bear
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Graf Von Rot the Bear
$12.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Kanata the Bear - Newfoundland
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Kanata the Bear - Newfoundland
$6.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Harrison the Bunny
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Harrison the Bunny
$9.00
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Koowee the Koala Bear
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Koowee the Koala Bear
$22.00
Only 1 left
Ty Buddy: Celebrate the Bear
Ty Ty Buddy: Celebrate the Bear
$10.00
Only 1 left
35th Anniversary Barbie - 11782
Mattel 35th Anniversary Barbie - 11782
From $40.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Zoom the Turtle
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Zoom the Turtle
$8.00
Only 2 left
Ty Beanie Baby: Goochy the Jellyfish
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Goochy the Jellyfish
$8.00
In Stock
Ty Beanie Baby: Sam the Bear - White
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Sam the Bear - White
$6.00
In Stock
Hallmark Ornament: 2012 Special Edition Precious Moment Rapunzel
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2012 Special Edition Precious Moment Rapunzel
From $39.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Giraffiti the Giraffe
Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Giraffiti the Giraffe
$10.00
Only 1 left

What Our Customers Are Saying

"My daughter took a shine to beanie babies at her local library and I was delighted to find Treasure Keeper offers such affordable toys with flat, affordable shipping. My daughter delighted in picking out her favorites and was overjoyed when they arrived."

--Andrea H. May 2024

"Love, love, love. Exactly as ordered and fast shipping meant I got my beanie baby quickly! 10 out of 10 would recommend."

-- Angelica T. June 2024

"I recommend Treasure Keeper due to their easy shopping website, fair prices, service and fast delivery! You place an order and the next business day, they ship your order, and they then email you the tracking, so you have an ETA for your order."

--David S. May 2023

Read More Reviews

Shop Figurines

View all
Lladró 5223 | Spring Is Here | Flower Petal BrokenLladró 5223 | Spring Is Here | Flower Petal Broken
Lladró Lladró 5223 | Spring Is Here | Flower Petal Broken
$68.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski Figurine: 238985 Crystal Planet | Millennium Edition | SCSSwarovski Figurine: 238985 Crystal Planet | Millennium Edition | SCS
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 238985 Crystal Planet | Millennium Edition | SCS
From $56.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Lladró Figurine: 7534 Dopey Dwarf
Lladró Lladró Figurine: 7534 Dopey Dwarf
From $230.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Department 56 Accessories | Carolers | David Copperfield | TreesDepartment 56 Accessories | Carolers | David Copperfield | Trees
Department 56 Department 56 Accessories | Carolers | David Copperfield | Trees
$55.00
Only 1 left
Hummel Goebel Goose Girl #1106 with Vase Hummel #625Hummel Goebel Goose Girl #1106 with Vase Hummel #625
Hummel Hummel Goebel Goose Girl #1106 with Vase Hummel #625
$45.00
Only 1 left
Department 56: 59862 Woodcutter and Son Set of 2 - Set of 2
Department 56 Department 56: 59862 Woodcutter and Son Set of 2 - Set of 2
From $20.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Precious Moments Figurine: 184101 Sugar Town Train Station
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 184101 Sugar Town Train Station
$9.00
In Stock
Precious Moments Figurine: 192368 Give Ability a Chance
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 192368 Give Ability a Chance
$15.00
In Stock
WDCC Millennium Mickey: On Top of the World | 1206254 | AS ISWDCC Millennium Mickey: On Top of the World | 1206254 | AS IS
Disney WDCC Millennium Mickey: On Top of the World | 1206254 | AS IS
$31.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski 174963 | Gosling Dick | Wrong BoxSwarovski 174963 | Gosling Dick | Wrong Box
Swarovski Swarovski 174963 | Gosling Dick | Wrong Box
$28.00
Only 1 left
Lladró Figurine: 5221 Sweet Scent
Lladró Lladró Figurine: 5221 Sweet Scent
From $75.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Lladró 1442 | Kitty Confrontation | Broken Flower PetalsLladró 1442 | Kitty Confrontation | Broken Flower Petals
Lladró Lladró 1442 | Kitty Confrontation | Broken Flower Petals
$72.00
Only 1 left

Shop By Brand

FREE Shipping!

All orders over $40 ship for FREE

SHOP NOW

Thousands of 5 Star Reviews

Two decades of experience + Our passion for service = A great buying experience for you!

VIEW OUR REVIEWS

Proud to Be a Family Business

Serving Families like yours since 1999

READ OUR STORY

Our Collections

View all
Lladró
Buddies
Swarovski Crystal
All Beanie Babies
All Barbies
Baby Ty & Pillow Pals
Winnie the Pooh
Mickey Mouse
Collection's name

Shop Designer Hand Bags

View all
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Navy Leather SatchelDooney & Bourke Purse: Navy Leather Satchel
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Navy Leather Satchel
$220.00
Only 1 left
Michael Kors Purse: Brown Bedford, MD Shoulder BagMichael Kors Purse: Brown Bedford, MD Shoulder Bag
Michael Kors Michael Kors Purse: Brown Bedford, MD Shoulder Bag
$180.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Green Leather SatchelDooney & Bourke Purse: Green Leather Satchel
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Green Leather Satchel
$220.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: 2158 Brown Signature Hobo BagCoach Purse: 2158 Brown Signature Hobo Bag
Coach Coach Purse: 2158 Brown Signature Hobo Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Vera Bradley Purse: Burgundy Crossbody BagVera Bradley Purse: Burgundy Crossbody Bag
Vera Bradley Vera Bradley Purse: Burgundy Crossbody Bag
$39.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: F54763 Black Leather BriefcaseCoach Purse: F54763 Black Leather Briefcase
Coach Coach Purse: F54763 Black Leather Briefcase
$220.00
Only 1 left
Rodo Purse: Black Sateen Evening HandbagRodo Purse: Black Sateen Evening Handbag
Rodo Rodo Purse: Black Sateen Evening Handbag
$80.00
Only 1 left
Leather School Purse: Florence Italy Brief Tote BagLeather School Purse: Florence Italy Brief Tote Bag
Leather School Leather School Purse: Florence Italy Brief Tote Bag
$85.00
Only 1 left
Aimee Kestenberg Purse: Grey Distressed Leather Hobo Shoulder HandbagAimee Kestenberg Purse: Grey Distressed Leather Hobo Shoulder Handbag
Aimee Kestenberg Aimee Kestenberg Purse: Grey Distressed Leather Hobo Shoulder Handbag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Ralph Lauren Purse: Green Leather Tote BagRalph Lauren Purse: Green Leather Tote Bag
Ralph Lauren Ralph Lauren Purse: Green Leather Tote Bag
$60.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: F10906 Brown Soho Hobo BagCoach Purse: F10906 Brown Soho Hobo Bag
Coach Coach Purse: F10906 Brown Soho Hobo Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Gucci Purse: Brown Leather Expandable Shoulder BagGucci Purse: Brown Leather Expandable Shoulder Bag
Gucci Gucci Purse: Brown Leather Expandable Shoulder Bag
$399.00
Only 1 left

Recently viewed