Treasure Keeper | Fine Collectibles & Toys

All Beanie Babies

Recently Restocked

Lladró Lladró Figurine: 7539 Sleepy Dwarf

From $148.00

Only 2 left

Disney Lot of 2: Little Mermaid and Rapunzel Ornaments

$67.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2004 Sneaking a Treat! | QRP4294

From $8.97

Only 3 left

Disney Disney The Seven Dwarves Diamond Mining Watch | Please Read

$83.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2007 Tinker Bell | QXD4279

From $10.00

Only 1 left

Disney Disney Sleeping Beauty Merriweather Ornament

$135.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2001 Tracking the Jagular | QXD4132 | Winnie the Pooh

From $11.89

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2010 Pooh Reflects on Christmas | QXD1016

From $7.00

Only 1 left

U.S. Mint 2009 Proof Silver Territories Quarter Set Gem Cameo No Box/COA

$68.20

Only 2 left

Department 56 Department 56: 55808 Violet Vender/Caroler/Chestnut Vendor - Set of 3

From $31.00

Only 2 left

Barbie Barbie 1602 | Italian Barbie

$77.00

Only 1 left

U.S. Mint 1958 Silver Proof Set (OGP) 5 coins

$69.00

Only 3 left

TY Ty Beanie Baby: Eggs 2005 the Bear

$11.00

In Stock

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2014 Feliz Navidad | QGO1523

From $7.97

Only 1 left

Save 15%

TY Ty Beanie Baby: Blarn-e the Irish Dog

$14.45 $17.00

Only 1 left

Department 56 Department 56: 55840 Theatre Royal

From $41.00

Only 2 left

TY Ty Beanie Baby: Secretariat the Horse

$31.00

Only 1 left

TY Ty Buddy: Chops the Lamb

$14.00

Only 1 left

TY Ty Buddy: Ferny the Bear

$25.00

Only 1 left

Department 56 Department 56: 55875 The Flat of Ebenezer Scrooge

From $43.00

Only 1 left

What Our Customers Are Saying

"We received a nice confirmation immediately on our order and the item was shipped right away. It was super well wrapped and arrived in perfect condition."

--Andre P. Sept. 2024

"This family business is awesome in every way! They're fair-priced, fast, and ethical, responding to any issues (however unlikely) with the best solution possible. You can trust this business to treat what you love with the same love you feel and you'll have your little treasure in no time"

-- Judith B. Sept. 2024

"I recommend Treasure Keeper due to their easy shopping website, fair prices, service and fast delivery! You place an order and the next business day, they ship your order, and they then email you the tracking, so you have an ETA for your order."

--David S. May 2023

Read More Reviews