Treasure Keeper | Fine Collectibles & Toys

All Beanie Babies

Recently Restocked

Disney Walt Disney Classics Collection: Magician Mickey

From $18.00

Only 3 left

Disney Walt Disney Classics Collection: Mickey Mouse - The Prince and the Pauper

From $35.00

Only 1 left

Disney WDCC Mickey Mouse - Presents for My Pals - Ornament | 41087

From $16.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2001 Tracking the Jagular | QXD4132 | Winnie the Pooh

From $11.89

Only 1 left

Disney Disney Sleeping Beauty Merriweather Ornament

$135.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2001 Mickey Mouse Velocipede - 1934 | QEO8552

From $20.89

Only 1 left

Disney WDCC Millennium Mickey: On Top of the World | 1206254 | AS IS

$12.75

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2005 Getting Ready for Christmas | QXD4212 | Disney

From $30.89

Only 1 left

Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Aria the Cat

$18.00

Only 2 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2006 GMC 1961 | QX2326 | Fire Brigade

From $19.89

Only 1 left

Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Zip the Cat - White Paws

$24.00

In Stock

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1998 Practice Swing - Donald Duck | QEO8396

From $6.00

Only 1 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1997 Ariel | QXI4072 | Disney

From $19.00

Only 1 left

Ty Ty Beanie Babies: 10 Randomly Selected Teddy Bears

$27.89

In Stock

Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Smitten the Bear - Pink Heart Nose

$8.00

In Stock

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2004 Plotting the Course | QXC4002

From $7.89

Only 1 left

Ty Ty Beanie Baby: Huggins the Dog

$14.00

In Stock

Save 15%

Department 56 Department 56: 59323 Old North Church

$24.65 $29.00

Only 2 left

Ty Ty Buddy: Dotty the Dalmatian

$20.00

Only 5 left

Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2009 Feliz Navidad | QSR4562

From $14.89

Only 1 left

What Our Customers Are Saying

"We received a nice confirmation immediately on our order and the item was shipped right away. It was super well wrapped and arrived in perfect condition."

--Andre P. Sept. 2024

"This family business is awesome in every way! They're fair-priced, fast, and ethical, responding to any issues (however unlikely) with the best solution possible. You can trust this business to treat what you love with the same love you feel and you'll have your little treasure in no time"

-- Judith B. Sept. 2024

"I recommend Treasure Keeper due to their easy shopping website, fair prices, service and fast delivery! You place an order and the next business day, they ship your order, and they then email you the tracking, so you have an ETA for your order."

--David S. May 2023

Read More Reviews